January 10th, 2018
Primary Vs. Team Nursing – Cost & conclusion
There were limited studies that evaluated the models of care with respect to associated costs via a primary evaluation. One such study compared the costs of primary nursing and those of team nursing based on a cost per patient day (PPD) by diagnostic related group (DRG). In this study, Gardner and Tilbury (1991) found out that primary nursing was less expensive when compared to team nursing. In a more recent review, Tiedeman and Lookinland (2004) find contradictory indications to the most cost-effective method when team and primary nursing are compared. Whereas some of the studies indicate team nursing to be more cost-effective compared to primary nursing, others note primary nursing to be the most cost-effective alternative, while others do not find the two models to differ in terms of cost (Tiedeman & Lookinland, 2004).
Use of different models of care may lead to varying patient, staff and organizational outcomes. This paper compares primary nursing and team nursing to assess the model that offers a better alternative with respect to quality of care, patient and staff satisfaction and cost. The study employs evidence drawn from a review of literature drawn from searches on online databases.
From the reviewed literature, there lacks adequate evidence to support the superiority of any of the methods in any of the aspects of evaluated. For instance, with regard to quality of care, whereas some studies indicate primary nursing to offer better outcomes when compared with team nursing (e.g. Sjetne et al., 2009), others do not find either method to convey any significant quality benefits over the other (e.g. Nissen, Boumans & Landerweerd, 1997) especially when nurses are assigned to a fixed team (Tiedeman & Lookinland, 2004). Similar findings are also noted with respect to staff satisfaction, although, among the studies reviewed, most supported the contention that primary nursing did improve staff and patient satisfaction when compared with team nursing. With respect to cost, only few studies that evaluated cost were retrieved with one study based on a primary evaluation (Gardner & Tilbury1991) indicating primary nursing to be more cost-effective when compared to team nursing, while a literature review had mixed findings when the two models were compared with respect to cost. Accordingly, there lacks adequate evidence to establish the superiority of either model with respect to the three aspects assessed especially with limited primary evaluation of the topic in current studies.
Dobson, S. & Tranter, S. (2008). Organising the work: choosing the most effective way to deliver nursing care in a hospital haemodialysis unit. Renal Society of Australasia Journal, 4(2), 59-63.
Fairbrother, G., Jones, A. & Rivas, K. (2010). Changing model of nursing care from individual patient allocation to team nursing in acute inpatient environment. Contemporary Nurse, 35(2), 202 – 220.
Gardner, K. G. & Tilbury, M. (1991). A longitudinal cost analysis of primary and team nursing. Nursing Economics, 9(2), 97-104.
International Council of Nurses – ICN. (2006). The global nursing shortage: priority areas for intervention. Geneva: ICN, retrieved from http://www.icn.ch/images/stories/documents/publications/GNRI/The_Global_Nursing_Shortage-Priority_Areas_for_Intervention.pdf
Makinen, A., Kivimaki, M., Elovainio, M., Virtanen, M. & Bond, S. (2003). Organization of nursing care as a determinant of job satisfaction among hospital nurses. Journal of Nursing Management, 11(5), 299 – 306, doi: 10.1046/j.1365-2834.2003.00399.x
Nissen, J. M. J. F., Boumans, N. P. G. & Landeweerd, J. A. (1997). Primary nursing and quality of care: a Dutch study. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 34(2), 93-102.
Sellick, K. J., Russell, S. & Beckmann, J. L. (2003). Primary nursing: an evaluation of its effects on patient perception of care and staff satisfaction. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 40(5), 265-273, doi:10.1016/S0020-7489(03)00064-6.
Sjetne, I. S., Veenstra, M., Ellefsen, B. & Stavem, K. (2008). Service quality in hospital wards with different nursing organization: nurses’ ratings. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 65(2), 325 – 336.
Tiedeman, M. E. & Lookinland, S. (2004). Traditional models of care delivery: what have we learned? Journal of Nursing Administration, 34(6), 291-297.